Race Realism Is Not Realistic And It Is Not Good Science

The recent resurgence of race-based pseudo-scientific discourse has sparked significant alarm among geneticists, evolutionary biologists, and social scientists. This intellectual movement, often cloaked in the terminology of "race realism" or "human biodiversity," posits that observable differences in human behavior, intelligence, and social outcomes are rooted in innate genetic disparities between racial groups. However, contemporary scientific consensus—backed by decades of genomic research—categorically rejects the validity of these claims, asserting that the concept of biological race lacks a genetic foundation.
The political climate surrounding these claims has intensified as prominent figures have begun integrating such narratives into mainstream policy discussions. During the World Economic Forum in Davos, former US President Donald Trump characterized populations from Somalia as possessing low IQs, a narrative echoed by Donald Trump Jr. in 2024 regarding Haitian migrants. These rhetorical shifts coincide with the rescinding of protected statuses for these groups, illustrating a tangible link between the promotion of "race science" and the implementation of restrictive state policies.
A Chronology of the Modern Resurgence
The roots of the current movement can be traced back to the mid-20th century, even as the global community formally distanced itself from the eugenics programs of the Nazi era. Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, fringe elements of the academic community sought to preserve hereditarian ideologies through journals like Mankind Quarterly, which received critical funding from the Pioneer Fund. Established in the 1930s by a textile magnate, the Pioneer Fund was instrumental in financing research aimed at maintaining segregation and promoting white supremacist theories.
In the 21st century, this network has evolved. The transition from the Human Diversity Foundation to entities such as Polygenic Scores LLC demonstrates a shift toward utilizing modern technical language to mask historical prejudices. The "London Conferences on Intelligence," which were held clandestinely at University College London before being exposed and subsequently moved, serve as a prime example of the community’s efforts to maintain a veneer of academic legitimacy. These gatherings provided a platform for proponents of hereditarianism to share findings that have been consistently rejected by mainstream scientific journals.

Genomic Complexity vs. Racial Categorization
The central pillar of "race science" is the assumption that human populations can be divided into discrete, genetically distinct categories that correlate with intelligence and behavior. This premise fails when subjected to the scrutiny of modern genomics. Since the 1970s, when evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin demonstrated that the vast majority of human genetic variation exists within populations rather than between them, scientific understanding has only become more nuanced.
Human genetic diversity is a mosaic, shaped by constant migration and interbreeding throughout history. Ancient DNA analysis has revolutionized the field, proving that there has never been a period of "genetic purity" for any human group. While certain physiological traits—such as skin pigmentation or lactase persistence—are geographically linked, these traits are adaptive responses to environmental pressures rather than markers of distinct, superior or inferior racial categories. Furthermore, many of these traits are found across disparate populations, refuting the notion that they are exclusive to a single racial lineage.
The Failure of the "National IQ" Database
A primary tool used by proponents of race realism is the "national IQ" database, a collection of statistics that claims to quantify the average intelligence of nations. Researchers in the fields of psychometrics and sociology have repeatedly identified this database as fundamentally flawed. The methodology suffers from severe selection bias and fails to account for the "Flynn effect," which describes the well-documented rise in IQ scores over the 20th century. This rise is far too rapid to be attributed to genetic changes and is instead a clear indicator of environmental factors, such as improvements in nutrition, healthcare, and educational access.
Critics of the database also note that IQ tests themselves are often culturally biased. These assessments, designed in Western contexts, rarely capture the diverse cognitive abilities—such as social intelligence or creative problem-solving—that are essential for human survival and societal success. By ignoring the "social brain hypothesis," which posits that human intellect evolved primarily to navigate complex social hierarchies, race scientists exclude a vital component of evolutionary biology. Mainstream research suggests that humans are remarkably uniform in their cognitive potential, with behavioral diversity being a testament to our species’ adaptability rather than a result of evolved psychological differences.
Institutional Challenges and Academic Freedom
The persistence of race science within academia is often defended under the guise of "academic freedom." However, the scientific method relies on peer review and rigorous empirical testing. When journals—even those within the social sciences—publish work that ignores established genomic evidence or relies on debunked statistical models, they undermine the integrity of the scientific community.

The case of Nathan Cofnas, who faced internal investigations at both Cambridge and Ghent University following his inflammatory claims regarding Jason Arday and his calls for a "hereditarian revolution," highlights the tension between institutional values and the promotion of pseudoscience. While universities are tasked with protecting free inquiry, they are also responsible for maintaining the rigor and ethics of the research conducted under their banners. The intervention of high-level diplomatic figures in these personnel matters underscores the political weight now attached to these academic disputes.
Broader Societal Implications
The consequences of legitimizing race science extend far beyond the ivory tower. By framing inequality as an inherent, biological feature of specific groups, this ideology provides a moral justification for discriminatory policies. If social disadvantage is perceived as a result of "innate defects," the responsibility of the state to address structural issues—such as systemic poverty, lack of educational opportunity, and health disparities—is effectively nullified.
Historical precedent demonstrates the danger of these theories. The eugenics movements of the early 20th century utilized the same "science" to advocate for forced sterilizations and, ultimately, to provide a pseudo-intellectual framework for the atrocities of the Holocaust. Today, the digital amplification of these ideas via social media platforms, including X (formerly Twitter), has accelerated the spread of extremist narratives, allowing them to bypass traditional academic gatekeepers and reach a wider public.
Conclusion
The scientific evidence is conclusive: race is a social construct, not a biological one. The "hereditarian" theories promoted by race realists fail to account for the complexity of the human genome, the impact of environmental factors on cognitive development, and the established principles of evolutionary biology. As the global community continues to grapple with increasing political polarization, it is imperative to distinguish between rigorous, evidence-based research and the re-packaging of century-old prejudices.
Science, at its best, is a self-correcting mechanism designed to uncover truth. Allowing the infiltration of ideological pseudoscience into this mechanism not only degrades public discourse but also provides fuel for policies that threaten the equality and dignity of human populations worldwide. The responsibility falls on academic institutions, media outlets, and the public to ensure that the pursuit of knowledge remains anchored in reality, rather than being redirected by those who seek to use the mask of science to justify the division of humanity.







